The scientific
fundamentals of our methods

DfACE builds on more than a decade of peer-reviewed research on circular economy systems conducted in industrial settings throughout Germany and Europe. This page documents the scientific foundations—the publications, concepts, and frameworks—that underpin every DfACE recommendation and make them externally verifiable.

Information technology
Data management, data-driven processes, and digital infrastructure are not our focus—that’s where specialized partners come in.
Engineering methology
We support technical product development—however, design for circularity using the DfACE methodology is the core of our services.
Recycling technology
We leave the evaluation and optimization of recycling processes, including life cycle assessments, to the experts at DfACE.
10R Framework

A comprehensive overview of where value enters your product, moves through it, and exits it

The assessment begins with a bill of materials analysis—every component, subcomponent, and material input is recorded by weight, volume, recyclability, and current disposal route. This establishes the baseline. The energy flow analysis covers the entire production cycle: raw material extraction and transport, manufacturing processes, the product’s use phase, and disposal. Each phase is evaluated in terms of its energy intensity and its potential for closing material loops. The characterization of waste streams identifies every material leaving the system—whether as scrap, offcuts, rejects, packaging, or end-of-life products—and classifies each stream by material type, volume, current disposal route, and market recovery potential.

Refuse: Non-consumption, avoidance, low utility

refers to the deliberate rejection of a product—that is, the decision not to develop, produce, or consume it. This approach is adopted when a product does not offer sufficient societal benefits within the circular economy. It may also be influenced by political, cultural, or regional factors.

Rethink: Redesign, Optimization, Recyclability

involves fundamentally rethinking and redesigning a product that is currently not recyclable. This may involve building on existing designs or require a greater investment in development. This approach is particularly relevant for innovative products for which no suitable recycling processes yet exist.

Reduce: Material savings, efficiency, conflicting objectives

aims to reduce material usage while maintaining the same functionality. Efficient use of materials is beneficial, but must not lead to premature component failure. At the same time, using less material can compromise the product’s future recyclability and cost-effectiveness.

Reuse: Same function, product preservation

refers to the repeated use of a product in its original form and for the same purpose. It is fully classified as product recycling and preserves the product’s integrity. It is clearly distinct from “repurposing,” in which the product’s purpose is changed.

Repair: Ease of disassembly, spare parts

refers to the repair of defective or worn components of a product. This requires that the design allow for easy access and that appropriate joining techniques be used to enable non-destructive disassembly. The approach also requires information, replacement parts, and organizational structures such as service offerings.

Refurbish: Refurbishment, restoration of quality, replacement parts

involves a comprehensive overhaul of a product to restore it to the best possible condition. During this process, not only defective components but also those that are potentially worn are inspected and, if necessary, replaced with identical parts. The process can also be performed by third-party providers and requires proper, non-destructive disassembly.

Remanufacture: Upgrade, performance enhancement, high complexity

goes beyond refurbishment by replacing components with more powerful new versions. As a result, the product can be restored to a condition even better than when it was new. This approach requires a high degree of organizational integration and information flow, and is particularly well-suited for high-quality, complex products.

Repurpose: Change of use, secondary use, substitution

refers to using a product for a purpose other than its original intended use. In doing so, some of the material may be used inefficiently, as the product is not optimized for the new purpose. Nevertheless, this approach can make economic sense if it replaces the manufacture of a new product.

Recycle: Material recovery, processing, process design

describes the dismantling of a product’s structure to recover materials. It is the fundamental end-of-life approach for all products and typically requires automated processes. Product design must therefore be tailored to the separability and process requirements of recycling technologies.

Recover: Energy generation, final option, loss

refers to the energy recovery of materials by extracting the energy they contain. After this process, both the product and the material are largely considered lost. This approach is used when other recycling options are not technically or economically feasible.

Publications

Supportive research

All of DfACE’s consulting services are based on published - including peer-reviewed - scientific papers.
The following publications form the core of our research.

12/2024
Chapter

Information as Key for Strategic Stakeholder Opportunities Within the Value Chain of an Advanced Circular Economy

Designing resource-efficient products, aided by digitalization, offers additional potential to consider improved circularity of the product for the whole value chain.
Authors: Phillip Wallat, Sebastian Lawrenz, Mathias Nippraschk
Abstract
12/2024
Chapter

Strategic Requirements-Based Product Design: A Tri-Tool Methodology For Advanced Circular Economy

Redesigning and updating products represent time-consuming processes, even if the same methodology as the original design is applied.
Authors: Phillip Wallat, Jiwei Low, Eldwin Darryl Tanzil
Abstract

Refine the circular economy by rethinking it -a holistic approach for the advanced circular economy

The Circular Economy is a recent economic approach aiming to transform the linear economy into a sustainable system including the economic, ecological, and social dimensions.
Authors: Mathias Nippraschk, Phillip Wallat, Sebastian Lawrenz, Daniel Goldmann
Abstract
05/2022
Article

A Knowledge-based Product Design Assistance for the Advanced Circular Economy

Information is crucial to establishing a circular economy. For example, the design engineer must access information regarding recycling processes.
Authors: Phillip Wallat, Sebastian Lawrenz, Armin Lohrengel
Abstract
01/2022
Poster

Is it all about Information?

The Role of the Information Gap between Stakeholders in the Context of the Circular Economy and how to close it
Authors: Mathias Nippraschk, Sebastian Lawrenz, Phillip Wallat, Armin Lohrengel
Abstract
01/2022
Book

Circular sPrint Playbook

The Circular sPrint format was developed by the CRAFTH project consortium which organized a total of four Circular sPrints events during 2020 and 2021, amidst the global Covid19 pandemic.
Authors: Tuomas Puttonen, Yannick Christiaens, Francesca Ostuzzi, Wim Van Opstal
Abstract

Der Einfluss der Fügetechnik auf die Konstruktion von Produkten für das Kreislaufwirtschaftssystem

To transform the current economic system towards a circular economy it is necessary to design products accordingly.
Authors: Phillip Wallat, Armin Lohrengel
Abstract
09/2021
Poster

A Knowledge-based Product Design Assistance for the Advanced Circular Economy

A Knowledge-based Product Design Assistance for the Advanced Circular Economy
Authors: Phillip Wallat, Sebastian Lawrenz, Armin Lohrengel, Andreas Rausch
Abstract

A Knowledge-based Product Design Assistance for the Advanced Circular Economy

Information is crucial to establishing a circular economy.
Authors: Phillip Wallat, Sebastian Lawrenz, Armin Lohrengel
Abstract

Is it all about Information? The Role of the Information Gap between Stakeholders in the Context of the Circular Economy

There is still a big difference, between a circular economy as described in the literature and reality.
Authors: Sebastian Lawrenz, Mathias Nippraschk, Phillip Wallat, Armin Lohrengel
Abstract

Creation of a materials database for digital systematization in the design process for circular economy-compliant products

Raw materials play a central role in the circular economy.
Authors: Phillip Wallat, Armin Lohrengel
Abstract

The Embedding of Circular Economy-Oriented Design Approaches into the Product Development Process

The circular economy contributes to securing raw materials and promoting resource efficiency.
Authors: Phillip Wallat, Armin Lohrengel
Abstract

Economic Factors Influencing Sustainable Product Development

A circular economy is only possible through appropriate product development.
Authors: Phillip Wallat, Armin Lohrengel
Abstract

Turn your products into  strategic assets

Circular economy strategies create measurable value across all areas of the business. Select an area to discover the specific benefits of DfACE at your level.